By Kabela Sumba. BSc. Eng.
At the beginning of this year, carbon tax was introduced in our nation. I totally oppose this theft in broad daylight as it is highly exaggerated and just another ploy by governments to squeeze even more money out of the pockets of tax-paying individuals. In Zambia, government has been quick to implement this carbon tax; most of the people don’t know what carbon tax is, much less carbon or its compounds.
Some officials even say it has been introduced to deal with carbon emissions. Since when did man begin discharging carbon into the environment? Carbon? The first correction to be made is that it’s compounds of carbon (carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide) being discharged and not the element itself. It is quite a challenge to begin to imagine how Zambian authorities can use this tax to reduce the effects of climate change. Human beings really think they can buy themselves out of decades of deforestation and massive factory emissions. It is very laughable.
This government efficiently thought up a method of collecting this tax, but plans have not been laid out as to how they will use this new resource. Will they patch up the sky? With pieces of ozone? Or will they use it to install a big air conditioner over the nation? And what about charcoal burners? Will they be taxed too? Personally I think the large manufacturers and the mines are the biggest polluters. They are the ones that should bear the larger chunk of this environmental debt.
It should be observed that in this nation, other areas of tax collection have not produced the results they purport to render, take for example “Musonko” (Road Tax). Every year billions of Kwacha (millions of dollars) are collected from car owners in form of tax which is meant to build and repair roads. If you were to drive to the Kitwe office of the Road Transport and Safety Authority today, I assure you will find that the road leading up to their office is not even maintained. Picture a slice of cheese in your mind, remove the yellow, paint it black and you have the road I am talking about.
Surely, if a government department fails to use road tax to fix roads, how can one possibly expect any other department to ‘mend’ the environment? The plain fact is that one feels the roughness of the road every time they make their way to this Road Transport Authority. Yes, everyone, including government-employed road tax collectors. If the potholes on that road are so evident and still nothing has been done about it, how can one start to believe that the government will mitigate the effects of a very gradual climate change, one so gradual you don’t even feel it. If there has been damage to the environment due to man’s activities, it is a mistake to think that money can solve this problem. Some things are just too big for man to accomplish. You can never make a pump big or strong enough to drain an ocean, or create a water tap large enough to flood the world.
At this point it should also be stated that there have been some serious errors made by some scientists computing figures. It comes as no surprise that while rushing to make the case for carbon tax and other green revenues, these scientists have, made tremendous mistakes such as switching the positions of a 35 and a 0 when compiling a report on the rate of melt of Himalayan glaciers: 2035 comes within a quarter of a decade while 2350 is 3 whole centuries away. It would not be paranoia on my part to suggest that the 2035 timeframe excited members of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, because it made a very strong case for the green cause, a scenario bearing close resemblance to that of a prime minister using a 45 minute timeframe to force his case for war through a parliament. Environmentalists need to be careful with how they analyze such data. The information coming from such panels must be carefully scrutinized before it is disseminated to the public. Organizations and governments, while making their case, should be careful not to instill fear in the public; the consequences could be very grave.
Needless to say, I get this feeling that all governments will eventually endorse this tax. What a window of opportunity, it couldn’t have come at a better time for Zambian policy makers. In effect, the total money paid out in tax per car-owning family has risen. Wouldn’t one suggest tax has somehow gone up, regardless of what it is for? Carbon tax collection will prove to be a very innovative means of introducing some kind of tax into the economy, in the place of openly hiking taxes. Carbon tax is the going to be the greatest trick this devil of a government pulled in the 21st century.
—————————————————————————
Extract from the author’s article: Carbon Tax – The Greatest Trick The Devil Pulled In The 21st Century, And A Few Other Tweaks Zambia Needs To Move Forward